Emergency Bivvy vs Blanket

Emergency bivy vs emergency blanket, which is which?
Emergency bivy vs emergency blanket, which is which?

Alright, let’s settle this once and for all: what’s the better ultralight piece of gear to have in your pack for emergency situations and overnighters: a bivy sack or an emergency blanket?

Both are wickedly lightweight, but they each have their own unique talents.

Let’s break it down and figure out which one deserves a spot in your kit.

What are Bivy Sacks?

Bivy sacks or bivouac sacks are great for protection and warmth
Bivy sacks or bivouac sacks are great for protection and warmth

You know those waterproof sacks that go over your sleeping bag? That’s a bivy (short for bivouac) sack. Basically, it turns your sleeping bag into a portable, weatherproof little sleeping nest.

Most of them are made from ripstop nylon or some other beefy but lightweight material.

Once you “install” on of those, you’ve got this cozy, protective shell around you while you snooze out in the open: no need to set up a tent or anything; you just unroll the bivy, hop in, and zip up.

Some even have mesh panels to keep the bugs away! Convenient right?

The Good, The Bad, and The Bivy

Like everything in life, the decision comes down to weighing the good and the bad
Like everything in life, the decision comes down to weighing the good and the bad

Pros of Using a Bivy Sack

  • Weather protection: these will shield you from wind, light rain, and maybe even a fresh dusting of snow. Plus, they trap in your body heat to keep you extra warm

  • Ultralight and packable: quality ultralight bivy sacks weigh just a few ounces and can stuff down tiny. Perfect for going stoveless on those long treks

  • Use it anywhere: bivy on the side of a mountain? Sure. Bivy hanging on a rock climbing ledge? You got it. These things are super versatile

  • Bug-Free Zzzzz’s: get a bivy sack with bug netting and say goodbye to waking up with mosquito bites all over your body

Cons of Using Bivy Sack

  • Condensation issues: without proper venting, things can get a little damp and clammy inside

    • Nobody likes waking up in a swampy sleeping bag

  • Cramped quarters: these are pretty much just big enough for you and your bag – there’s not a lot of space to move around comfortably

  • No floor: you’ll need to pair a bivy with a sleeping pad or mat to insulate you from the cold ground below

What’s an Emergency Blanket?

Emergency blanket, space blanket, or thermal blanket - you name it!
Emergency blanket, space blanket, or thermal blanket – you name it!

These things look pretty unassuming—they’re just a thin, crinkly sheet made from a special heat-reflecting material. But don’t let their simple appearance fool you:

  • Emergency blankets (sometimes called space blankets) can actually retain up to 90% of your body heat. Talk about efficiency…

  • In survival situations, you can use them as makeshift shelters or ground insulators, or just wrap them around you to stay warm when the temperatures drop abruptly

  • Endurance athletes and hardcore minimalist hikers swear by these for preventing hypothermia when Mother Nature decides to throw a tantrum

Pros and Cons of the Emergency Blanket

Emergency blankets are also not perfect
Emergency blankets are also not perfect

Pros

  • Ultra-ultralight gear: we’re talking a few grams at most. Practically weightless

  • Multi-talented: use them for warmth, signaling rescuers, creating shelters, and even collecting water. Almost like a survival Swiss army knife

  • Dirt cheap: you can snag a basic one for just a couple of bucks, a total bargain for a potentially life-saving item

  • Tiny package: these things can get stuffed into the most microscopic of spaces in your backpack when not in use

Cons

  • Limited weather protection: they’ll reflect your body heat back to you, but don’t offer much defense against wind, rain, or ground moisture

  • Not built to last: their material is delicate and prone to tearing if you’re not careful

  • Open season for bugs: no mesh = no insect protection on your exposed skin

  • A symphony of crinkling: using one of these can sound like the world’s noisiest chip bag. Not ideal for stealthy situations

So Which One Takes the Ultralight Camping Crown?

The best for you will depend on your specific outdoor activities and personal preferences
The best for you will depend on your specific outdoor activities and personal preferences

Obviously, it comes down to your specific needs and the conditions you’ll be facing out there:

  • Bivy sacks are the way to go if you want a complete minimalist sleeping system with reliable weather resistance and bug defense

    • They will keep you dry, warm, and itch-free while still being light and portable

  • But if you just need an ultra-ultralight backup option for preventing hypothermia or building an emergency shelter

    • You really can’t beat the convenience and low cost of an emergency blanket

    • Just know that it won’t squat against rain or swarming insects

Why Not Rock Both for the Ultimate Adventure Setup?

Two is better than one, right?
Two is better than one, right?

Carrying both an ultralight bivy sack and an emergency blanket might be the perfect combo.

The bivvy acts as your main weatherproof sleeping zone, while you keep that trusty blanket on hand for emergency heat retention or shelter construction duty.

Two crucial pieces of gear double your survival potential!

You could even get wild and line the inside of your traditional bivy sack with an emergency blanket for an extra thick layer of toasty warmth on those frigid winter camping trips. Just be careful not to puncture the blanket on any zippers or sharp edges inside the bivy.

Don’t Forget the Rest of Your Sleep System

You won't go far if you just bring a bivvy sack
You won’t go far if you just bring a bivvy sack

Whichever route you take for the bivy or blanket part of the equation, remember that a good night’s sleep requires the full package.

You will always have to consider elements like:

  • Sleeping bag: the foundation of your sleeping system, for crucial insulation and warmth

  • Sleeping pad or sleeping mat: cushy comfort from tent floors and an insulating layer from the cold ground below

  • Tent or tarp: when you need legit shelter from bad weather, these have your back

By thinking through each part of the system and how they’ll work together, you can assemble a lightweight, high-performance sleeping setup that’ll keep you safe, warm, and well-rested no matter what the trail throws your way.

Pack the Other 9 Essentials Too

Want more? Consider these other essentials when preparing for outdoor adventures
Want more? Consider these other essentials when preparing for outdoor adventures

Speaking of safety and survival, it’s always a smart move to have the rest of the essentials ready to rock along with your sweet bivvy or emergency blanket setup:

  1. Navigation (map, compass, GPS…because who likes getting lost?)

  2. Sun protection (sunscreen, sunglasses)

  3. Insulation

  4. Illumination (headlamp, flashlight)

  5. First-aid supplies

  6. Fire (matches, lighters)

  7. Repair kit and tools

  8. Nutrition

  9. Hydration

With the right preparation and gear dialed in, you can take on anything like a champ, whether it’s a quick overnighter or a multi-week backcountry suffer-fest.

Stay safe out there, and get ready to make some ultralight, ultralegend memories.

Recent Posts

Gone are the days of flimsy tents with the mind-blowing advancement in tent technology
Tents
Admin

Tent Technology

When you hear the word “tent,” you probably picture roasting marshmallows and ghost stories around the campfire, right? Well, hold

Read More ➚

stay up to date

Copyright © 2024 RTIVITIES. All rights reserved